Anonymous asked:
Hi please I'm new here so I'm begging you not to be mad at me for my question. I'm genuinely just trying to form an opinion. I just want to know how Harry's not benefiting from his closet. Louis is definitely being punished and there's nothing nice about his Mr I am in fact straight with a child image but w Harry he gets to play both sides and wear a dress and work in Hollywood. It also confuses me how Harry's songs seem to be him begging not to be left and I'm like??Something's not adding up
I’m not mad at you, but I’m not a research robot who can just spit out answers the second someone wants them. I just don’t have the time or energy to continually prove things to people. I’m sorry that that makes it harder for some new fans, but I’m exhausted. This line of questioning has been going in for well over a year and I just can’t do it every time a new fan discovers this band or has a question. .
All I can say is that someone accusing him of “benefitting” from being closeted, doesn’t understand what it’s like to be closeted. No one would choose to lie about such an enormous part of who they are unless they felt they had to. Feel free to search my blog for tags like
The only song I can think of on Fine Line that even comes close to Harry “begging not to be left” is Falling. I answered someone about Falling recently, here (including links to some other people’s analyses).
When he spoke with Zane Lowe, he said about Falling: “I kind of started to feel like threads of you know, where I could see myself becoming someone that I didn’t want to be.” Harry has spoken about how the sequencing of his songs is so important and how much time it took to get right, He also has said that this song, in particular, is “very centered in what the record is… centered in a time that a lot of the record was kind of built around”. So I think it’s important that Falling is in the middle of the album, smack between the first group of songs that are all about the euphoria of first falling in love, and the second group of songs that seem to be about rediscovering and deepening love, and learning to understand yourself on a deeper level.
Just because someone has a period of deep unhappiness, feeling abandoned, feeling like all is lost, doesn’t mean it’s the overall theme of their life (or album). And there’s a huge assumption (based on the way the narrative of this album was pushed) that what Harry is talking about in a song like this is the end of a romantic relationship. But I honestly believe so much of Fine Line (the album) is actually about Harry’s relationship with himself and with gender. And I think Falling can be looked at through that lens, as well. Especially if we think about what he said about Falling being centered in a time that much of the record was built around. Being afraid of losing themselves and/or their parter because of gender confusion is not exactly uncommon (this analysis discusses the concept from Louis’ POV)
I’m not saying there aren’t songs about romantic struggles, but I think people are trying too hard to look at their albums and say aha! They’re together. Or aha! They broke up. And I just think it’s a lot more complex.
For many of us, Harry and Louis’ relationship is the primary reason we’re here. But when you’re settled in a long term relationship, it’s unlikely that everything you want to express as an artist is about your love life. Harry grappling with his gender identity seems to have been of much greater importance to him while making FL. Here’s a tag for posts on Harry’s Gender.
As for the rest of the album, please just search my song analysis tag. There’s lots there.






















